The Best One-Watch Collection

Jamie Morton Tuesday, November 28th, 2023 10 min. read

The best one-watch collection is just that, one watch for life. A constant companion someone will want to wear for decades. For many, it’s a foreign concept because, let’s face it, it’s hard to buy just one watch and stop there with so many outstanding options available today. However, many passionate collectors are attracted to the simplicity of owning just one watch, and we are on a quest to help them with a brief list of the timepieces we think fit the bill for the best one-and-done watch collection. 

Read Also:
Choosing a 3-Watch Collection

Top Choice For a One-Watch Collection: Omega Speedmaster Professional

The stainless steel Omega Speedmaster has an enduring quality about it. The Speedmaster Professional model of today hardly looks different than one made 60 years ago, and it’s been a fixture on the wrists of astronauts, celebrities, and ordinary horology enthusiasts for decades. It isn’t a stretch to assume it will still be an influential and reliable watch for life and possibly for future generations. There’s also the question of functionality. As the brand’s resident chronograph, the Speedmaster is a practical, everyday tool for measuring elapsed time. It can act as a simple stopwatch, or the tachymeter bezel can calculate the hourly rate of a repetitive task.

Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch Watch
REF: 310.30.42.50.01.001
Speedmaster Professional Moonwatch Watch Ref. 310.30.42.50.01.001

Ref. 310.30.42.50.01.001 is the current production model Speedmaster Professional, with ties to the past and future of watchmaking. The latest, and quite possibly greatest, Omega caliber 3861 manual-winding movement drives the watch and promises a longer 50-hour power reserve, better anti-magnetism than previous calibers, and the title “Certified Master Chronometer.”  If you’re committing to one watch, it might as well be one with unparalleled precision.

Loading, please wait…

Outwardly, ref. 310.30.42.50.01.001 embraces a timeless aesthetic heavily inspired by the 4th generation Omega that once traveled to the Moon. It sports a similar aluminum “Dot over 90” bezel, Hesalite crystal, step dial, and twisted “Lyre” lugs. The stainless steel model also looks exceptional on nearly any strap, including steel, leather, and rubber. It’s easy to switch up the look of the watch from casual to sporty or formal.

Key Features: Omega Speedmaster Professional ref. 310.30.42.50.01.001

Model:Omega Speedmaster Professional
Reference Number:310.30.42.50.01.001
Case Size: 42mm
Crystal:Hesalite
Bezel:  Tachymeter, Aluminum “Dot over 90”
Dial: Black “Step”
Movement:Caliber 3861
Functions:Chronograph, hours, minutes, small seconds.
Price: $6,600 Retail, Approx. $5,395 Pre-Owned
Omega Speedmaster Professional specs

Read Also:
How Much Does An Omega Speedmaster Cost?
Are Omega Watches A Good Investment?
Daniel Craig Teased a New White Omega Speedmaster

Rolex Submariner Ref. 126610

When it comes to one-watch collections, the Rolex Submariner 126610 is a sound option because it uses superior materials that will stand the test of time. At the same time, it boasts the effortless style and functionality of an industry-leading dive watch. It looks sharp tucked under the cuff of a black tux yet keeps perfect time hundreds of meters below the ocean’s surface. With that much versatility and style range, the Submariner is a smart choice for a once-in-a-lifetime watch.

Rolex Sub
Rolex Submariner Date Ref: 126610LN

Rolex has released many iterations of the Submariner since the 1950s, including some in solid gold and two-tone. However, none is as consistently sought-after as the legendary stainless steel model outfitted with a classic black dial and bezel. A design set that is often imitated but never duplicated. Ref. 126610 is the latest model, with the highly anticipated caliber 3235 Perpetual movement, contemporary 41mm case, and durable Rolex Oystersteel bracelet. Rolex’s patented Chromalight, which was quietly upgraded in 2022, lends itself to hours of legibility in dark environments, while the almost-unscratchable Cerachrom insert promises resistance to normal wear and tear. 

Loading, please wait…

We can’t forget about the Submariner’s excellent dive watch functionality. While it wasn’t the first professional dive watch on the scene in the 1950s (well, some people argue that it was), the Submariner is easily one of the most influential. It offers water resistance up to 300 meters/1,000 feet on current-production models and is outfitted with a unidirectional timing bezel for safe underwater timekeeping, plus its Glidelock extension clasp provides arguably the best on-the-fly adjustment on the market.

Key Features: Rolex Submariner Date Ref. 126610LN

Model:Rolex Submariner Date
Reference Number:126610LN
Case Size: 41mm
Crystal:Sapphire
Bezel: 60-Minute, Unidirectional, Ceramic “Cerachrom”
Dial:Black, Chromalight
Movement:Caliber 3235
Functions:Hours, Minutes, Seconds, Date
Price: $10,250 Retail, Approx. $13,000 Pre-Owned
Rolex Submariner Date 126610 specs

Tudor Black Bay GMT Ref. M79830RB

A stylish dual-time watch is another contender for our list, particularly for anyone who travels often, has vested interests in other time zones, or appreciates the look of a classic pilot’s watch. Add a substantial depth rating and a perfectly executed vintage-inspired design set to the mix, and you’ve got all the makings of a fantastic lifelong timepiece. That watch, of course, is the Tudor Black Bay GMT ref. M79830RB.

Tudor Black Bay GMT Ref. M79830RB
Tudor Black Bay GMT Ref. M79830RB

When Tudor released this model just a few years ago, many keen-eyed collectors were quick to notice that the Tudor Black Bay GMT closely resembled the legendary GMT-Master/GMT-Master II produced by sister company Rolex, even going so far as to sport a similar red and blue “Pepsi” bezel. The muted, darker hues on the Tudor bezel are reminiscent of a genuine vintage watch, matching the overall vintage-inspired vibe presented throughout the rest of the broader Black Bay series. It has all the appeal of a famous Pepsi GMT without the premium accompanying a Rolex watch. At a fraction of the price, the Tudor Black Bay GMT is an excellent choice if you have concerns about wearing a $10,000+ Rolex on your wrist day in and day out.

Loading, please wait…

Aside from their inherently timeless aesthetic, Black Bay watches are suited for a lifetime of wear and built to last using modern materials, such as scratch-resistant sapphire and longer-lasting luminescent hour markers and hands. The same goes with the modern caliber MT5652 movement, which has a silicon balance spring, quickset date, and 70-hour power reserve.

Key Features: Tudor Black Bay GMT Ref. M79830RB

Model:Tudor Black Bay GMT
Reference Number:M79830RB
Case Size: 41mm
Crystal:Sapphire
Bezel: 24-Hour, Bidirectional, Anodized Aluminum
Dial:Black
Movement:Caliber MT5652
Functions:GMT, Hours, Minutes, Seconds, Date
Price: $4,375 Retail, Approx. $3,500 Pre-Owned
Tudor Black Bay GMT specs

Rolex Datejust Ref. 116234

Another solid choice for a one-watch collection is a simple, three-hand timepiece with a calendar mechanism like a modern pre-owned Rolex Datejust. Ref. 116234 in White Rolesor flies under the radar with a versatile white metal finish and classy white dial. It has a slightly elevated look to it with the white gold fluted bezel that glitters as the wrist moves. The nice thing about this watch is that you don’t need to switch out the strap to make it more wearable. It’s perfect as-is. The best part is that the Datejust comes in a dizzying variety of design sets if this model doesn’t speak to your watch tastes, and Datejust prices are relatively reasonable as far as Rolex watches go.

ROLEX
Datejust 36 White Roman Dial Watch
REF: 116234
Rolex Datejust 36 White Roman Dial Watch Ref. 116234

For this list, we chose the time-honored favorite, Datejust 36mm. It has that classic Rolex dress watch silhouette that will suit a range of wrist sizes, from men to women. The Datejust was the first mechanical wristwatch to offer an automatically changing date display. While this feature is a fixture in the watchmaking industry today, it was pretty revolutionary when the collection debuted in 1945 and is arguably a must-have for an everyday watch.

Loading, please wait…

Reliability is another concern for the perfect lifelong watch, and the Rolex Datejust has it in spades. The Oyster case is hermetically sealed, protecting the movement from dust and moisture, and the Perpetual movement boasts self-winding and a prestigious COSC distinction – perfect for constant wear.  

Key Features: Rolex Datejust Ref. 116234

Model:Rolex Datejust
Reference Number:116234
Case Size: 36mm
Crystal:Sapphire
Metal Finish:White Rolesor – Stainless Steel and 18k White Gold
Dial:White
Movement:Caliber 3135
Functions:Hours, Minutes, Seconds, Date
Price:$7,950 Retail, Approx. $8,500 Pre-owned
Rolex Datejust 116234 specs

Rolex Oyster Perpetual Ref. 124300

The perfect one-and-done collection includes a practical watch, both in functionality and style. As Rolex’s signature, time-only dress watch, the Oyster Perpetual delivers. The collection has been in production longer than most of the Rolex catalog and was among the first models to sport both the legendary Oyster case and the Perpetual movement. By leaving out the date, the dial takes on a cleaner, more utilitarian aesthetic, particularly on newer models with the 41mm case, luminescent baton indices, and sleek Oystersteel finish.

ROLEX
Oyster Perpetual 41 Coral Red Dial Watch
REF: 124300
ROLEX Oyster Perpetual 41 Coral Red Dial Watch REF: 124300

Ref. 124300 took the market by storm when it debuted in 2020 with a larger 41mm case size, next-generation movement, and a fresh and contemporary selection of Stella-inspired dial colors like turquoise, yellow and coral red. Collectors rushed to their ADs to get their hands on the bold and vibrant new offerings. A colorful watch face has redeeming qualities but doesn’t stand the test of time. We are also thankful that Rolex included classically elegant dial options with the new release, such as black, blue, and silver. If we were to wear the same watch for the rest of our lives, most would choose one with an understated dial color.

Loading, please wait…

Like the Datejust, the modern Oyster Perpetual ref. 124300 has a classic dress watch silhouette that we expect will always be in style.

Key Features: Rolex Oyster Perpetual Ref. 124300

Model:Rolex Oyster Perpetual
Reference Number:124300
Case Size: 41mm
Crystal:Sapphire
Metal Finish:Oystersteel
Dial:Lacquer with Chromalight-filled hour markers (various colors)
Movement:Caliber 3230
Functions:Hours, Minutes, Seconds
Price:MSRP: $6,400
Market Price: $9,000-$29,000 (Varies by color)
Rolex Oyster Perpetual 41 specs

Read Also:
The Best Rolex Oyster Perpetual Alternatives
What is the Best Entry-Level Rolex?
Most Popular Rolex Watches

Precious Metal One-Watch Collection: Zenith Ultra-Thin

The Zenith Elite Ultra-Thin is a beautifully minimalist watch. Featuring a lustrous rose gold finish and measuring 40mm in diameter and approximately 7.6mm thick, ref. 18.2010.681/11.C498 excels in wrist presence and comfort. While precious metal isn’t typically the first choice for a daily driver or lifelong watch, this slightly unconventional choice will appeal to the open-minded collector with a sharp eye for high style.  

ZENITH
Elite Ultra-Thin Watch
REF: 18.2010.681/11.C498
ZENITH Elite Ultra-Thin Watch REF: 18.2010.681/11.C498

What really caught our eye was the understated elegance of the dial, which we can see on any wrist and during any era. Roman numerals are set against a classic white dial, accompanied by long-tapered hour and minute hands and a small seconds sub-dial at 9 o’clock. 

Key Features: Zenith Elite Ultra-Thin Ref. 18.2010.681/11.C498

Model:Zenith Elite Ultra-Thin
Reference Number:18.2010.681/11.C498
Case Size: 40mm
Metal Finish:18k Rose Gold
Dial:White
Movement:Caliber Elite 681
Functions:Hours, Minutes, Small Seconds
Price:Approx. $7,995 Pre-Owned
Zenith Elite Ref. 18.2010.681/11.C498 specs

Loading, please wait…

From purpose-driven tool watches to sophisticated dress watches, countless contenders for the best one-watch collection exist. We hope this brief list has inspired you in your search for the last watch you will ever need to own. 

More Collecting Tips
Best Rolex Oyster Perpetual Alternatives
Best Rolex Datejust Alternatives
5 Mistakes Watch Collectors Make That You Can Avoid
The Ultimate Watch Collection Under $25K for Your Style